Music video theory

This is America-Music video

1) The music video This is America meets a lot of the key conventions of a music video despite it having an underlying narrative its trying to tell. Its very performance orientated with Childish Gambino being at the forefront of the video and staring at the camera intently (direct address). The video even has backup dancers/singers in the background.

2) The music video comments on gun violence and deconstructs Americas false reality of being a place of safety. Throughout the video the black community seems to be minding they're own business but get shot down for no reason whilst the people in the background seem to just clean everything up and act like nothing happened. This video presents these problems of racism and gun violence through the narrative in the music video.

3) 

  • Gilroy The black Atlantic- Throughout the video it could be claimed that the black community doesn't have a place of belonging since whatever they do or wherever they go they get discriminated on. This relates to Gilroys theory of black diasporic identity.
  • Stuart Hall- Childish Gambino could be seen as "the clown/entertainer" if we apply Stuart Halls characterisation of black characteristics in media. He's there to tell the audience a narrative but at the same time it could be argued that hes also entertaining consumers.
  • Rose and Dyson- This is America supports Rose's idea of hip-hop giving audiences insight into the experiences of young black men and giving them a voice or platform to express they're problems. However this goes against her view that currently hip-hop is being exploited and corrupted by capitalism 
4) The three interpretations are:
  1. Hes playing Jim Crow
  2. Hes duping us with the dance
  3. Taking on the police
5) Some of the alternative explanations for the music video are:
  • "Its just music" This most likely means that its entire purpose was simply to entertain consumers and that its priority was always to be a performance rather then talk about the issues revolving around America.
  • "Childish Gambino shows his humanity by showing and condemning random violence" From this persons perspective they believe that the artist is trying to demonstrate how dangerous America is for the black community and that hes trying to shed light on this issue. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

TV end of Unit index

Introduction to TV Drama Capital Case Study Capital: Marxism and Hegemony Deutschland 83 case study Postmodernism and Deutschland Industries: Rise of foreign language TV Dramas Industries: Impact of new digital media on TV
Read more

Blog Feedback

  WWW: You started really well with the film poster analysis and your mise-en-scene analysis tasks. I really like the choice of still image to analyse and you’ve also picked out some good elements of the mise-en-scene in the Get Out scene. You’ve written in some detail for those first two blog tasks and that’s something you want to continue and build on as the course develops because A Level is a very demanding standard. EBI: The isolation and illness going around this half-term have made things very tricky but it’s now crucial that we get back on top of the workload because constantly being behind makes for a tough year. You are missing four pieces on the coursework side but I’m confident you’ll be able to catch those up over half-term. Remember, for the mise-en-scene recreation you can now simply submit detailed planning rather than the full video. In terms of your analysis work, the key feedback is regarding the depth and detail required at A Level – just as you demonstrate in your
Read more

Sound Analysis

Image
1)  Clockwork Orange-  The music choice isn't what I would expect from this type of scene from that movie with all the chaos going on around it as the guy hits them all into the water and holds a knife. I believe the director chose this music to show us what hes thinking not just from there internal monologue but through non diagetic sound. The characters mind sees his actions as methodical and planned so everything going on is within his control.   Funny Games- At the beginning the music seems to be parallel to whats going on in the scene with a nice calm and classic song maybe trying to show that the family is just your everyday normal group of people. Then near the middle the music takes a drastic shift and becomes contrapuntel to whats going on. The director might be trying to say that underneath the façade of them being normal they're lives are in constant chaos. The 2nd music was loud and a obnoxious. The narrative might delve into how a stereotypical family would react t
Read more